Unfortunately, the clash of pectin-rich ketchup and acid-rich horseradish can be the reason why your homemade cocktail sauce ...

Instead of mixing shrimp with cocktail sauce, start by spreading softened cream cheese at the bottom of a serving dish. Then, layer cocktail sauce on top, followed by chopped, cooked shrimp.

Plump black tiger shrimp. Refreshing tomato sauce. All combined to make - [coughing] Spiciest shrimp cocktail in America. [rock music] Shoot! Today, I'm in my home state of Indiana to try the ...